The Latest

Back to the Storyboard: Throwing it All Out

Reading Time: 1

There are times when I reach design enlightenment: I have a clear vision of exactly what I want to do and I’m fully capable of realizing that vision. There are other times when I really don’t know what to do and I have to struggle with an idea for a while before I find something that I love. And then there are times like this one, where I thought I knew where I was going but, after struggling with the idea for the better part of the week, I realize that I hate everything.

lmmuh

What do You Do?

At time like this, the best thing to do is to throw it all away and start over. That can be exceedingly difficult, especially if you liked your original idea but just can’t seem to make it work. But whether the project is personal, like this one, or something you’re doing for work, the bottom line is, you’ll waste a ton more time and end up with something you’ll never feel truly satisfied with if you persist in trying to plow through with an idea you can see isn’t working instead of being willing to chuck it. So, this weekend, I went back to the storyboard.

The Change

When I say I chucked it, I mean I chucked everything, except the idea of a video in the intro. See for yourself.

Original Sketch

The original prototype sketch

Try 1

I was all set to go with an underground thing. You might notice that the vid here shows the Arc de Triomphe. I always intended to change that. It’s no good showing a Parisian landmark in a London-themed course. But that wasn’t what was bothering me.

One of the things I didn’t like was the dark theme I had going on here. Somehow I just couldn’t keep going with that. Bright and fresh seemed more appropriate, perhaps because I was basing my idea on AirBNB.

Still, the main problem though was that I wasn’t 100 percent on the way the activities themselves should look and work. I had maps on the brain. I was thinking London underground map for the main them, and then a map of London boroughs would form the base for the initial interactions (you can see them in my original sketch). But the more I tried to make this work, the more it struck me as the wrong direction. I mean, who cares which borough the London eye is in. That isn’t really how most travelers navigate things. The important bit was focusing the interaction on finding the right attractions for the customers, not locating the attractions.

travellydemo

Redesign

This weekend, I finally allowed myself to chuck everything out and start over. I took major  inspiration from the Allen Interactions Expedia case study, AirBNB, Twitter, and Pinterest. Importantly (for me. at least) I took a step back from Storyline and made some time to create a storyboard in PowerPoint. I know that some people are okay jumping right into the development tool, but I’ve always found that to be a problem when I don’t have a clear vision. By removing my work to a more throw-away workspace like PowerPoint or paper, it’s easier for me to think big and let go. I definitely recommend it if you ever have trouble pinning down a good design.

 

travellydemo2

What Are You Designing?

Any one else working on this month’s GDS Challenge? What are you designing?

3 Comments

  1. May 25, 2015 - Reply

    […] As you saw in a previous post, I completely revamped my entire challenge look. At first, I was going for something more underground-centric, but it didn’t seem to fit. So I decided to start afresh. I drew a lot of inspiration from AirBNB’s site and visuals. Context-wise, I wanted to ground the training firmly in  a sort of site back end, where a customer service agent might be able to look up rooms and research London. […]

  2. Nadine Monn
    June 10, 2015 - Reply

    Kristin, this is a great post! Thanks for showing your work and sharing your thought process.

    I think we — as instructional designers and developers — all have this experience at some point but it’s helpful to see how others approach it. The hardest part of the redesign or re-envisioning is if the client loved what we had. I’ve been lucky that the one time I had to trash the initial design idea and change it up, I was able to show my client how the new one would work better. (We hadn’t 100% formalized the initial concept but I knew she liked it a lot.)

    Also, I found myself saying “Yes!” to needing to get back into PowerPoint to play with the design, rather than in Storyline. I usually start in PowerPoint because I feel more in control to change the design there and moving it over to Storyline isn’t that difficult.

    • June 10, 2015

      Thanks so much for your comment, Nadine! I’ve been getting myself in the habit of drawing things first. For my personal projects, I typically don’t storyboard because my vision is usually very clear. For this one though, that wasn’t working.
      I’ve heard several people recommend developing prototypes right in your authoring tool. While that’s totally possible, I’ve always found that that places too much of a psychological block to throwing it out (for me, anyways). So I always go back to PowerPoint because, for me, it’s easier to just leave it and start again if an idea isn’t working.

Drop a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *